MLB — Lineups that win

Team record whenever every listed player was in the starting lineup (starting batting order), from ESPN box scores. Groups active in 2025 or 2026, sorted by win rate; minimum games shown in each table. Win rates on small samples regress hard — use the games column.

Starting pairs

Best

Players	Team	G	W-L	Win%	Run line	Margin
Tyler Rogers + LaMonte Wade Jr.	SF	57	51-6	90%	40-17	+1.90
Wilmer Flores + Tyler Rogers	SF	50	43-7	86%	33-16	+1.86
Shohei Ohtani + Santiago Espinal	LAD	30	25-5	83%	20-10	+3.97
Mike Yastrzemski + Tyler Rogers	SF	81	67-14	83%	56-25	+1.51
Travis Jankowski + Jeff McNeil	NYM	40	33-7	82%	25-14	+1.85
Brandon Nimmo + Travis Jankowski	NYM	39	32-7	82%	24-14	+1.69
Francisco Lindor + Travis Jankowski	NYM	44	36-8	82%	28-15	+1.86
Travis Jankowski + Pete Alonso	NYM	44	36-8	82%	28-15	+1.86
Eugenio Suarez + Victor Robles	SEA	31	25-6	81%	23-8	+2.68
Mookie Betts + Justin Dean	LAD	30	24-6	80%	17-13	+2.23
Santiago Espinal + Andy Pages	LAD	34	27-7	79%	22-12	+3.50
Freddie Freeman + Santiago Espinal	LAD	33	26-7	79%	21-12	+3.33
Chas McCormick + Zach Dezenzo	HOU	36	28-8	78%	23-13	+2.06
Jake Cronenworth + Bryce Johnson	SD	103	80-23	78%	70-33	+2.11
Adam Frazier + Tyler Tolbert	KC	31	24-7	77%	20-11	+2.48
Isaac Paredes + Chas McCormick	HOU	35	27-8	77%	26-9	+1.89
Andrew Vaughn + Brandon Lockridge	MIL	30	23-7	77%	20-10	+3.40
Max Muncy + Santiago Espinal	LAD	30	23-7	77%	18-12	+3.30
Kyle Tucker + Santiago Espinal	LAD	30	23-7	77%	18-12	+2.93
Dominic Smith + Ronald Acuna Jr.	ATL	47	36-11	77%	31-16	+2.77
Jorge Barrosa + Ryan Waldschmidt	ARI	41	31-10	76%	28-13	+2.05
Francisco Lindor + Edwin Diaz	NYM	53	40-13	76%	30-23	+1.17
Luis Arraez + Bryce Johnson	SD	89	67-22	75%	57-32	+1.88
Jose Iglesias + Bryce Johnson	SD	36	27-9	75%	27-9	+2.61
Bryce Johnson + Jackson Merrill	SD	103	77-26	75%	66-37	+1.70
Petey Halpin + Angel Genao	CLE	39	29-10	74%	24-15	+1.77
William Contreras + Cooper Pratt	MIL	74	55-19	74%	39-35	+1.43
David Hamilton + Roman Anthony	BOS	35	26-9	74%	24-11	+1.74
Luisangel Acuna + Brett Baty	NYM	69	51-18	74%	39-30	+1.64
Sal Frelick + Cooper Pratt	MIL	46	34-12	74%	25-21	+1.24
Josh Lowe + Kameron Misner	TB	38	28-10	74%	25-13	+2.29
Chris Taylor + Tommy Edman	LAD	49	36-13	74%	32-17	+2.04
Spencer Horwitz + Billy Cook	PIT	49	36-13	74%	33-16	+2.14
Henry Davis + Billy Cook	PIT	49	36-13	74%	35-14	+2.08
Orlando Arcia + Eli White	ATL	41	30-11	73%	20-21	+1.66
Nick Allen + Jeremy Pena	HOU	63	46-17	73%	46-17	+1.97
Manny Machado + Bryce Johnson	SD	118	86-32	73%	76-42	+1.69
Christian Walker + Chas McCormick	HOU	59	43-16	73%	41-18	+1.48
Aaron Judge + Jose Caballero	NYY	92	67-25	73%	58-34	+2.19
Christian Vazquez + Nick Allen	HOU	44	32-12	73%	31-13	+1.25

Worst

Players	Team	G	W-L	Win%	Run line	Margin
Hunter Goodman + Yanquiel Fernandez	COL	37	5-32	14%	12-25	-3.84
Ezequiel Tovar + Yanquiel Fernandez	COL	37	6-31	16%	10-27	-4.24
Corey Julks + Korey Lee	CHW	53	9-44	17%	25-28	-1.87
Andrew Benintendi + Corey Julks	CHW	40	7-33	18%	16-24	-2.15
Ryan McMahon + Nick Martini	COL	34	6-28	18%	16-18	-2.50
Nick Martini + Hunter Goodman	COL	34	6-28	18%	16-18	-2.79
Brenton Doyle + Adael Amador	COL	39	7-32	18%	15-24	-3.56
Alan Trejo + Hunter Goodman	COL	33	6-27	18%	11-22	-3.09
Mickey Moniak + Nick Martini	COL	33	6-27	18%	16-17	-2.67
Nick Martini + Michael Toglia	COL	33	6-27	18%	16-17	-2.70
Tyler Freeman + Yanquiel Fernandez	COL	38	7-31	18%	13-25	-4.03
Jordan Beck + Yanquiel Fernandez	COL	43	8-35	19%	14-29	-4.05
Michael Toglia + Adael Amador	COL	42	8-34	19%	20-22	-2.93
Starling Marte + Bobby Witt Jr.	KC	41	8-33	20%	13-28	-2.02
Kyle Farmer + Ezequiel Tovar	COL	50	10-40	20%	20-30	-3.64
Brenton Doyle + Yanquiel Fernandez	COL	35	7-28	20%	11-24	-3.14
Ryan McMahon + Adael Amador	COL	44	9-35	20%	21-23	-2.57
Kyle Farmer + Hunter Goodman	COL	78	16-62	20%	38-40	-2.78
Hunter Goodman + Adael Amador	COL	63	13-50	21%	30-33	-2.44
Kyle Farmer + Michael Toglia	COL	58	12-46	21%	28-30	-2.79

Starting trios

Best

Players	Team	G	W-L	Win%	Run line	Margin
Wilmer Flores + Tyler Rogers + LaMonte Wade Jr.	SF	33	30-3	91%	22-11	+2.03
Wilmer Flores + Mike Yastrzemski + Tyler Rogers	SF	41	37-4	90%	30-11	+2.07
Aaron Judge + Jose Caballero + Jasson Dominguez	NYY	30	27-3	90%	24-6	+3.90
Mike Yastrzemski + Tyler Rogers + LaMonte Wade Jr.	SF	48	43-5	90%	37-11	+1.96
Jorge Barrosa + Tim Tawa + Ryan Waldschmidt	ARI	26	22-4	85%	20-6	+3.12
Brendan Rodgers + Chas McCormick + Jake Meyers	HOU	25	21-4	84%	18-7	+2.36
Andrew Vaughn + Brandon Lockridge + Joey Ortiz	MIL	25	21-4	84%	20-5	+4.44
Christian Walker + Chas McCormick + Jake Meyers	HOU	31	26-5	84%	24-7	+2.35
Eugenio Suarez + Jorge Polanco + Victor Robles	SEA	30	25-5	83%	23-7	+2.80
Jorge Polanco + Victor Robles + Josh Naylor	SEA	30	25-5	83%	23-7	+2.80
Shohei Ohtani + Santiago Espinal + Andy Pages	LAD	30	25-5	83%	20-10	+3.97
Brandon Nimmo + Travis Jankowski + Jeff McNeil	NYM	35	29-6	83%	21-13	+1.66
Freddie Freeman + Shohei Ohtani + Santiago Espinal	LAD	29	24-5	83%	19-10	+3.79
Francisco Lindor + Travis Jankowski + Jeff McNeil	NYM	40	33-7	82%	25-14	+1.85
Travis Jankowski + Jeff McNeil + Pete Alonso	NYM	40	33-7	82%	25-14	+1.85
Chas McCormick + Jake Meyers + Zach Dezenzo	HOU	34	28-6	82%	23-11	+2.47
Francisco Lindor + Brandon Nimmo + Travis Jankowski	NYM	39	32-7	82%	24-14	+1.69
Brandon Nimmo + Travis Jankowski + Pete Alonso	NYM	39	32-7	82%	24-14	+1.69
Aaron Judge + Jose Caballero + Anthony Volpe	NYY	39	32-7	82%	26-13	+2.85
Francisco Lindor + Travis Jankowski + Pete Alonso	NYM	44	36-8	82%	28-15	+1.86
Isaac Paredes + Chas McCormick + Jake Meyers	HOU	33	27-6	82%	25-8	+2.12
Aaron Judge + Ryan McMahon + Jasson Dominguez	NYY	33	27-6	82%	23-10	+3.00
Mookie Betts + Teoscar Hernandez + Justin Dean	LAD	27	22-5	82%	15-12	+2.33
Teoscar Hernandez + Shohei Ohtani + Justin Dean	LAD	27	22-5	82%	15-12	+2.33
Teoscar Hernandez + Justin Dean + Andy Pages	LAD	27	22-5	82%	15-12	+2.33
Anthony Seigler + Jarren Duran + Masataka Yoshida	BOS	27	22-5	82%	18-9	+2.56
Anthony Seigler + Masataka Yoshida + Wilyer Abreu	BOS	27	22-5	82%	18-9	+2.56
Anthony Seigler + Masataka Yoshida + Caleb Durbin	BOS	27	22-5	82%	18-9	+2.56
Max Muncy + Shohei Ohtani + Santiago Espinal	LAD	27	22-5	82%	17-10	+3.81
Tyler Wade + Bryce Johnson + Jackson Merrill	SD	26	21-5	81%	18-8	+2.27
Andy Ibanez + Zach McKinstry + Jace Jung	DET	26	21-5	81%	19-7	+3.15
Brendan Rodgers + Isaac Paredes + Chas McCormick	HOU	26	21-5	81%	18-8	+2.15
Brendan Rodgers + Chas McCormick + Jeremy Pena	HOU	26	21-5	81%	18-8	+2.15
Freddie Freeman + Teoscar Hernandez + Justin Dean	LAD	26	21-5	81%	14-12	+2.27
Kyle Tucker + Shohei Ohtani + Santiago Espinal	LAD	26	21-5	81%	16-10	+3.38
Anthony Seigler + Masataka Yoshida + Ceddanne Rafaela	BOS	26	21-5	81%	17-9	+2.50
Eugenio Suarez + J.P. Crawford + Victor Robles	SEA	31	25-6	81%	23-8	+2.68
Eugenio Suarez + Victor Robles + Josh Naylor	SEA	31	25-6	81%	23-8	+2.68
Eugenio Suarez + Victor Robles + Randy Arozarena	SEA	31	25-6	81%	23-8	+2.68
Eugenio Suarez + Victor Robles + Julio Rodriguez	SEA	31	25-6	81%	23-8	+2.68

Worst

Players	Team	G	W-L	Win%	Run line	Margin
Matt Thaiss + Andrew Vaughn + Miguel Vargas	CHW	27	3-24	11%	13-14	-2.19
Matt Thaiss + Luis Robert Jr. + Andrew Vaughn	CHW	25	3-22	12%	13-12	-1.88
Matt Thaiss + Miguel Vargas + Brooks Baldwin	CHW	25	3-22	12%	12-13	-2.00
Hunter Goodman + Ezequiel Tovar + Yanquiel Fernandez	COL	30	4-26	13%	8-22	-4.00
Luis Robert Jr. + Korey Lee + Brooks Baldwin	CHW	35	5-30	14%	13-22	-2.69
Brenton Doyle + Hunter Goodman + Yanquiel Fernandez	COL	28	4-24	14%	8-20	-3.46
Hunter Goodman + Jordan Beck + Yanquiel Fernandez	COL	34	5-29	15%	11-23	-3.85
Matt Thaiss + Luis Robert Jr. + Miguel Vargas	CHW	27	4-23	15%	14-13	-1.74
Andrew Vaughn + Korey Lee + Brooks Baldwin	CHW	33	5-28	15%	13-20	-2.54
Starling Marte + Bobby Witt Jr. + Jac Caglianone	KC	32	5-27	16%	11-21	-1.94
Ryan McMahon + Kyle Farmer + Ezequiel Tovar	COL	25	4-21	16%	10-15	-2.88
Matt Thaiss + Andrew Vaughn + Brooks Baldwin	CHW	25	4-21	16%	13-12	-1.72
Byron Buxton + Trevor Larnach + Mickey Gasper	MIN	25	4-21	16%	8-17	-2.36
Andrew Benintendi + Andrew Vaughn + Brooks Baldwin	CHW	48	8-40	17%	20-28	-2.25
Kyle Farmer + Michael Toglia + Hunter Goodman	COL	48	8-40	17%	23-25	-3.02
Alan Trejo + Brenton Doyle + Hunter Goodman	COL	30	5-25	17%	10-20	-3.67
Brenton Doyle + Jordan Beck + Adael Amador	COL	30	5-25	17%	12-18	-3.60
Brenton Doyle + Hunter Goodman + Adael Amador	COL	35	6-29	17%	14-21	-3.57
Mickey Moniak + Michael Toglia + Adael Amador	COL	29	5-24	17%	16-13	-3.24
Mickey Moniak + Hunter Goodman + Yanquiel Fernandez	COL	29	5-24	17%	10-19	-3.62